Only To Thinking

Only To Thinking

Emily Spotts

The Tragedy of the Species, Part One

Emily Spotts's avatar
Emily Spotts
Oct 24, 2022
∙ Paid

[Enter ME, MOTHER, BROTHER, DOG, and CHARLES DARWIN.]

MOTHER: What a nice meal! Chicken and eggs… I wonder which came first.

Thanks for reading Only To Thinking! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

BROTHER: The chicken came first!

ME: The egg came first!

DARWIN: In fact, it was-

[Knocking is heard at the door. I walk towards the door to greet our new guests. Enter philosopher ARISTOTLE, Mortal Kombat character QUAN CHI, and particle physicist RICHARD FEYNMAN.]

ARISTOTLE: Aristotle is here!

QUAN CHI: Behold, the great sorcerer Quan Chi!

FEYNMAN: It is I, Richard Feynman!

DOG: [Growls.]

MOTHER: I don't think she likes you, Aristotle. 

ARISTOTLE: Impossible! All like Aristotle!

BROTHER: She looks unhappy.

ARISTOTLE: Aye, looks; but the dog cannot feel unhappy, for an animal's soul does not allow for emotion!

QUAN CHI: No soul? What makes you think dogs lack souls? I know for certain you speak wrongly.

DOG: [Snarls.]

ARISTOTLE: Impossible! What purpose would a dog have for emotion?

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
Emily Spotts's avatar
A guest post by
Emily Spotts
© 2026 Only To Thinking · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture